Introduction
A banana taped to a wall is again shaking up the art world, fetching a staggering $6.2 million at a New York Sotheby’s auction. Named Comedian, the tongue-in-cheek piece by the Italian conceptual artist Maurizio Cattelan is a touchstone of the insanity, and genius, of modern art.
Debuting at Art Basel Miami Beach in 2019, Comedian made international headlines as both a meme and an indictment of the art market’s obsession with the cutting edge. The work in question, a single banana taped to a wall with duct tape, fetched between $120,000 and $150,000 at Art Basel. It is not only still the talking point of art world controversies, but its reappearance at Sotheby’s with a new record-breaking sale only underscores its relevance.
A Mysterious Purchaser with a Big Gesture
The successful bid was from the founder of the cryptocurrency platform Tron, Justin Sun. Sun, who has made headlines in the past with his daring investments — tech and art — has said he plans to eat the banana as part of his “living art” experience. In a statement about the purchase, Sun compared Comedian to internet memes, describing it “a perfect commentary on the intersections of art, pop culture and commerce.” Sun’s plans have provoked fierce debate. Others praise his reworking of the piece as a participatory performance, and yet others fret that eating the banana, a perishable material component of the artwork, could detract from its enduring conceptual legacy.
What Exactly Did Sun Buy?
The $6.2 million price tag isn’t for the fruit or the tape, though. Instead, the buyer is given a certificate of authenticity along with instructions on how to display the art. It’s the idea, not the materials, that matters in Comedian, Cattelan has argued. “Owners can replace the banana when it’s needed,” to keep the piece “alive,” he said. Art critics have not been slow to come forward. Others see Comedian as a satirical critique of the art market’s love of spectacle, while still others consider it the apotheosis of conspicuous emptiness in the art world.
Public Reaction
The sale has reignited those debates over the value and meaning of conceptual art. On social media, critics and fans have been quick to voice opinions, with hashtags like #BananaArt and #MaurizioCattelan trending internationally. “Memes of everyday objects taped to walls as jokes have made a resurgence, parodying how simple the piece is.”
“The work challenges us to grapple with questions of value, transience and the place of humor in art,” said the art historian Linda Carlson. It sounds like the punchline of a bad joke, but comedian: It’s a pretty serious joke.”
A Mark of Contemporary Art’s Excesses?
With all its haters, Comedian remains one of the great crowd-pleasers of the past several years—call it a work that flips the finger to anyone who says they know what art can and should do. Whether it is being hailed as a brilliant criticism of the vainglorious nature of art or derided as a nihilistic stunt, the duct-taped banana has certainly earned its place in the annals of art history.
For now, the world watches to see whether Sun’s intentions to eat the banana will signal a new chapter for this notorious artwork — or its final annihilation.
Contributor
