How a 70-Year-Old Art Heist Finally Cracked
A mystery that has riddled the art community for decades has now finally been solved. The criminal was a respected British art expert. Leonard Gerald Gwynne Ramsey, known as LGG Ramsey was once editor of the prestigious journal The Connoisseur. He has now, albeit posthumously been exposed as the man behind the 1951 theft of The Portrait of Wolfgang Wilhelm of Pfalz-Neuburg by Anthony van Dyck.
The painting in question is part of a treasured collection housed at Boughton House in Northamptonshire, popularly known as “the English Versailles.” It was stolen during a routine visit. At the time, Ramsey had exclusive access to view the estate’s paintings while preparing an article for the 1952 edition of The Connoisseur’s Year Book. When he left, one small but significant artwork was missing.
However, the theft was discovered when Six years later, the wife of Boughton House’s owner, the Duchess of Buccleuch, found a strikingly familiar portrait in an American museum. To her shock, the painting bore an uncanny resemblance to the missing Van Dyck. What followed was an investigation spanning decades. The rite ended in the painting being returned to its rightful home — thanks to the determined research of art historian Dr. Meredith Hale from the University of Exeter.
Piecing Together the Puzzle
Hale’s breakthrough came through meticulous detective work. She discovered a 1953 letter from art expert Ludwig Goldscheider. In the letter, he talked about authenticating the painting at Ramsey’s request. Further records revealed that, in 1954, the artwork was sold through Christie’s in London. Though the seller’s identity was initially obscured, Hale traced it back to a Bond Street dealer, Eugene Slatter, who had acted on Ramsey’s behalf.
Ramsey had used his position of influence and network of art-world connections to orchestrate the sale. His ability to manipulate the system, coupled with his reputation, allowed him to commit what was, in effect, the perfect crime—at least for a time. The painting changed hands multiple times before finally being loaned to the Fogg Art Museum at Harvard University in 1957.
Art Theft Cold Case Solved!
The painting’s discovery in 1957 was a sheer coincidence. While visiting the Fogg Museum, the Duchess of Buccleuch recognized the artwork, triggering an investigation into its provenance. Records at Boughton House confirmed what she feared: the painting was indeed missing from the family’s collection.
The Duke of Buccleuch formally requested its return, but unravelling the tangled web of deceit proved difficult. Correspondence from the time reveals a frustrating back-and-forth between the Duke, the Fogg Museum, and Christie’s, with Ramsey and his associates offering flimsy explanations. One claim suggested that the painting had been purchased at a market stall in Hemel Hempstead, a story that quickly fell apart under scrutiny.
Art historian Kenneth Clark, a former director of the National Gallery, expressed his scepticism in a letter to the Duchess, stating that Ramsey and Goldscheider “both make a bad impression.” He noted how Goldscheider initially authenticated the painting but later tried to distance himself from his certificate, raising further suspicions of complicity.
The Legacy of Lost Masterpieces and Recovery Efforts
Despite overwhelming circumstantial evidence, proving Ramsey’s guilt beyond doubt at the time was nearly impossible. The case faded into obscurity, and the painting remained out of the family’s reach for decades. It wasn’t until Hale’s research unearthed new evidence that momentum built for its restitution.
By 1981, the painting had found its way into the University of Toronto’s art collection as part of a bequest. The university had no reason to suspect anything was amiss—until Hale presented her findings. In 2022, after legal discussions and negotiations, the university formally returned the artwork to the Duke of Buccleuch, bringing the long-sought resolution to the case.
The Legacy of a Scandal
The revelation that a respected art expert had masterminded such a brazen theft has sent shockwaves through the art world. Professor Robin Simon, editor of the British Art Journal, condemned Ramsey and his collaborators as “crooks,” expressing disbelief at how long it took for justice to be served.
The case also highlights the vulnerabilities in the art world’s provenance system. Institutions and collectors rely on trust and scholarly integrity—qualities that Ramsey exploited. His position as editor was a perfect cover to commit art theft and launder stolen works through reputable dealers and auction houses.
As for Hale, her tireless efforts not only solved a 70-year-old mystery but also restored a stolen masterpiece to its rightful place. “My research led to it being returned,” she said, acknowledging the arduous process of negotiating its restitution.
Boughton House can now proudly display The Portrait of Wolfgang Wilhelm of Pfalz-Neuburg once again, a testament to the enduring power of justice—and the unrelenting pursuit of the truth in the art world.
Image Courtesy – Phys.org
Contributor
